A column in the Journal recently argued that Americans "hate" [macro-]economics because it over turns common sense (for example that paying people to not work leads to less working) and -- unlike, for example, physics which can be equally counter-intuitive -- does not, generally, work.
The counter-claim that macro-economic conclusions are strongly data-driven, is easy to call into question.
For example, the President's nominated Chief Economist is, in part, known for research showing there is no economic benefit to elite undergraduate education. This conclusion is only superficially data-driven. It turns out -- unsurprisingly -- that, controlling for objective academic measures, elite college grads do economically better. In other words, Penn alumni with 1400 SAT scores tend to make more money then Penn St. alumni with the same scores.
To get around this, Krueger suggests there are un-observed material variables -- such as "motivation and creativity." In an initial paper, he modeled these factors by schools a student was accepted to. He found that students accepted to, for example, Penn with equivalent SAT scores were likely to make equivalent money even if they chose to attend Penn St. In a later paper, he found "quality of schools applied to" a more precise proxy.
This is, of course, crazy-talk. Common sense dictates the following: A Wharton finance major is likely to make a lot more then a Penn St finance major; Concentrating on women's and religious studies is not a recipe for economic success whether from Penn or Penn St; A C student has better prospects from Penn than Penn St.; Some students are better served by Penn St. and, knowing who they are, more likely than others to turn down Penn; Quality of school applied to says more about social resources and expectations than intrinsic motivation or creativity (which are, in any case, likely the stronger factors).
Which is all to say: Students ought think twice before dumbly following what Dr. Krueger (B.S. Cornell '83, Ph.D. Harvard '87) says. And Conservatives are absolutely right to be skeptical of the "data-driven" conclusions of macro-economic models.
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Sunday, August 7, 2011
Galuth
"Galuth" is, perhaps, the most powerful and contemporary Jewish conception. We are taught that it was not only the Jews who were exiled with the destruction of their Temple -- G-d, Himself, was as well. Where some see a world in which "God is dead," the Jewish tradition teaches that He is merely in exile. And not because we, today, do not believe in Him faithfully enough. Rather, because, we have not been good enough to each other.
Monday, August 1, 2011
Heads I Win, Tails You Lose
In the high stakes poker game, they were playing, Boehner folded.
As described by the President, the new deal is staged:
The President made absolutely clear in his statement that the substance of the negotiations -- tax raises vs spending cuts -- weren't going to change. In effect, what this deal does is switch the "hostage" from the debt limit to defense and seniors. Which is to say from a hostage many in the GOP -- who believe smaller government leads to economic growth -- would be happy to sacrifice. The committee it sets up will give equal weight to House Democrats and Republicans despite the 2010 elections that gave republicans an almost 2-1 edge.
Finally, and above all, there is absolutely nothing in this deal that would motivate Democrats to compromise. Should the committee come back empty handed, they would gleefully look forward to arguing to voters that crazy Republicans skewered Defense and Seniors to protect "the rich".
In other words, politically, Republicans would be well advised to trash this deal -- argue that Obama's insistence on playing politics with Defense spending renders him an unfit Commander-In-Chief -- and roll the dice on default.
As described by the President, the new deal is staged:
The first part of this agreement will cut about $1 trillion in spending over the next 10 years... the second part... establishes a bipartisan committee of Congress to report back by November with a proposal to further reduce the deficit... To hold us all accountable for making these reforms, tough cuts that both parties would find objectionable would automatically go into effect if we don’t act.
The threatened tough cuts would be to defense and medicare providers. The President made absolutely clear in his statement that the substance of the negotiations -- tax raises vs spending cuts -- weren't going to change. In effect, what this deal does is switch the "hostage" from the debt limit to defense and seniors. Which is to say from a hostage many in the GOP -- who believe smaller government leads to economic growth -- would be happy to sacrifice. The committee it sets up will give equal weight to House Democrats and Republicans despite the 2010 elections that gave republicans an almost 2-1 edge.
Finally, and above all, there is absolutely nothing in this deal that would motivate Democrats to compromise. Should the committee come back empty handed, they would gleefully look forward to arguing to voters that crazy Republicans skewered Defense and Seniors to protect "the rich".
In other words, politically, Republicans would be well advised to trash this deal -- argue that Obama's insistence on playing politics with Defense spending renders him an unfit Commander-In-Chief -- and roll the dice on default.
Monday, July 25, 2011
Obama's Rhetoric
While it would be a mistake to take the President's political rhetoric more seriously than it ought be, two observations from his address last night.
The President appears fond of his professor moments. He likes saying things like "I won’t bore you with the details of every plan or proposal, but basically, the debate has centered around..." and "something known as the debt ceiling -- a term that most people outside of Washington have probably never heard of before." He even felt the need to explain that should we default, "we would not have enough money to pay all of our bills" One imagines that liberals find such rhetoric smugly self-affirming whereas conservatives bristle.
He also repeated his now oft-used line about asking "hedge fund managers to stop paying taxes at a lower rate than their secretaries." This argument is somewhat ambiguous.
The term "Hedge Fund Managers" can refer to the companies that manage hedge funds. A big portion of their revenue is proportional to the returns they generate and allowed to be taxed as capital gains (~15%), rather than ordinary income (~35%). While there are good arguments for taxing this revenue at the higher rate, doing so will certainly reduce employee compensation, including for secretaries. In other words, raising taxes on fund management firms will indirectly, but surely, raise taxes on those firm's secretaries.
"Hedge Fund Manager" may also refer to the fund's principles, many of whom earn staggering figures by investing their own money. This return is absolutely investment income and taxed appropriately. An attempt to better discriminate, to have different classes of investors pay wildly divergent tax rates would very much appear confiscatory.
The President appears fond of his professor moments. He likes saying things like "I won’t bore you with the details of every plan or proposal, but basically, the debate has centered around..." and "something known as the debt ceiling -- a term that most people outside of Washington have probably never heard of before." He even felt the need to explain that should we default, "we would not have enough money to pay all of our bills" One imagines that liberals find such rhetoric smugly self-affirming whereas conservatives bristle.
He also repeated his now oft-used line about asking "hedge fund managers to stop paying taxes at a lower rate than their secretaries." This argument is somewhat ambiguous.
The term "Hedge Fund Managers" can refer to the companies that manage hedge funds. A big portion of their revenue is proportional to the returns they generate and allowed to be taxed as capital gains (~15%), rather than ordinary income (~35%). While there are good arguments for taxing this revenue at the higher rate, doing so will certainly reduce employee compensation, including for secretaries. In other words, raising taxes on fund management firms will indirectly, but surely, raise taxes on those firm's secretaries.
"Hedge Fund Manager" may also refer to the fund's principles, many of whom earn staggering figures by investing their own money. This return is absolutely investment income and taxed appropriately. An attempt to better discriminate, to have different classes of investors pay wildly divergent tax rates would very much appear confiscatory.
Debt Politics
The President, in his speech tonight, reached out to the sort of independent who likes "balance" and "compromise". In his, Boehner spoke to the sort of independents who, back in the day, supported Perot. In that the latter are more likely voters, Boehner played the stronger card.
The founding fathers dealt Boehner perhaps the strongest card in preventing the Senate from initiating a revenue bill (i.e.: A bill the Republican house would not support). The proposed Senate bill very much works to the G.O.P.'s political favor. Accepting it, in the last minute will take some air out of the claim they are un-compromising extremists, they will honestly take home to their base the best deal they could get, and it will put real teeth into the 2012 election.
Boehner's proposed two-step process is likely less politically advantageous. It will give the Democrats, before the election, another opportunity to frame Republicans as stooges of the very-wealthy and, most dangerously, it will give the President another chance to finally appear a strong and effective leader.
The founding fathers dealt Boehner perhaps the strongest card in preventing the Senate from initiating a revenue bill (i.e.: A bill the Republican house would not support). The proposed Senate bill very much works to the G.O.P.'s political favor. Accepting it, in the last minute will take some air out of the claim they are un-compromising extremists, they will honestly take home to their base the best deal they could get, and it will put real teeth into the 2012 election.
Boehner's proposed two-step process is likely less politically advantageous. It will give the Democrats, before the election, another opportunity to frame Republicans as stooges of the very-wealthy and, most dangerously, it will give the President another chance to finally appear a strong and effective leader.
NFL Settlement
From: ... To: Sent: Monday, July 25, 2011 12:04 PM Subject: Have No Fear.... Degenerate Football Fans- The league, the NFLPA and myself have reached a settlement, and there will be the Confidence/Rank Em pool for the 2011/2012 season. A more detailed email will be forthcoming, but it will be comparable in format to past years (weekly winners, cumulative winners, etc.) As spots often go quickly, please let me know if you are interested. Also, if you know others that may be interested, please let me know. Thanks, and I hope you are all enjoying your summer. ________________________________________ From: [ME] Sent: Monday, July 25, 2011 12:43 PM To: ... Subject: Re: Have No Fear.... I'm interested. But I believe we should cap the potential winnings of new entrants for the first five years they are in the pool at 30% of the stated prizes, and divide any excess amongst those of us who have been in the pool the longest (and thus have contributed the most to the pool pots over the years). Just to be fair. And we should set some of that money taken from the new entrants aside for people who used to be, but are no longer, in the pool. To compensate them for their sacrifices and contributions to the success of the pool.
Wednesday, July 13, 2011
The Debt Limit
A WSJ op-ed argues that "The tea party/talk-radio expectations for what Republicans can accomplish over the debt-limit showdown have always been unrealistic... Republicans might have played this game better, but the truth is that Mr. Obama has more cards to play." According to the op-ed:
In a separate column, Rove argues that the Government has sufficient revenue for debt payments, Social Security benefits, Medicaid and Medicare, active duty military pay, Department of Defense vendors and IRS refunds. In other words, that the political consequences of not raising the limit are bearable. As not raising the debt limit will set a hard cap on Federal spending and give the President, in effect, a line item veto to enforce, why would fiscal conservatives support raising it? The President will be politically constrained in his spending choices -- imagine the blow-back if he continued to pay six figure salaries to political appointees while cutting social security.
While Republicans have no political -- or principled -- interest in a debt limit deal, they would be wise to offer proposals that framed "Spending as a percent of GDP" as the issue. Failing that, they may have difficulty countering the President's intended claim that he "offered" the largest deficit cuts.
The polls that now find that voters oppose a debt-limit increase will turn on a dime when Americans start learning that they won't get Social Security checks. Republicans will then run like they're fleeing the Pamplona bulls, and chaotic retreats are the ugliest kind. By then they might end up having to vote for a debt-limit increase and a tax increase.
The Journal is correct only in that if the Republicans do not have the courage of their convictions, bluffing will end badly. In a separate column, Rove argues that the Government has sufficient revenue for debt payments, Social Security benefits, Medicaid and Medicare, active duty military pay, Department of Defense vendors and IRS refunds. In other words, that the political consequences of not raising the limit are bearable. As not raising the debt limit will set a hard cap on Federal spending and give the President, in effect, a line item veto to enforce, why would fiscal conservatives support raising it? The President will be politically constrained in his spending choices -- imagine the blow-back if he continued to pay six figure salaries to political appointees while cutting social security.
While Republicans have no political -- or principled -- interest in a debt limit deal, they would be wise to offer proposals that framed "Spending as a percent of GDP" as the issue. Failing that, they may have difficulty countering the President's intended claim that he "offered" the largest deficit cuts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)